murksofus wrote:
we played correctly.
I hate to be negative, but I just don't believe you.
You must have made mistakes and broken at least one rule.
(There are many good suggestions above, but I'd bet that you weren't turning round cards in to ships every round.)
Why don't you try to replicate the game and record each action. (I challenge you to make me eat my words.)
If you can either video it, or list every single action taken, then maybe I will believe your claim.